The Perplexing College Admissions Process

The Perplexing College Admissions Process

Learning from other individuals experiences is among the most readily useful techniques to avoid problems and mistakes when undertaking an endeavor that is new. One of the most complex endeavors these times may be the university admissions process. You will find therefore variables that are many possibilities for apparently random results that getting the good thing about other candidates’ war tales can be key to assisting you avoid pitfalls. In the event that you will likely be signing up to university this autumn, the next information could possibly be quite helpful to you.

There is an interesting — and very long — thread on the College Confidential discussion forum that details some ‘applicants’ war stories.’ What makes you ridiculously mad in regards to the college admissions process? explores, across 520 posts, the issues that perplex and also possibly enrage college applicants and their moms and dads. While the qualifier ‘ridiculously’ in the thread’s title can be a bit on the top, you will find certainly aspects of the college process that have reached minimum inconvenient, infuriating and possibly, at worst, temper-tantrum inducing.

Meeting Deadlines Presents Challenges

From my own viewpoint, having been through the college procedure cycle with a child and son, I am able to recall being forced to counsel and ‘encourage’ my son to generally meet a short-fuse deadline for publishing their EA application to 1 college. This is back the rock chronilogical age of paper applications, but points out of the kinds of problems applicants can encounter, even when things be seemingly going efficiently. Thus, my war that is brief story

A publishing error caused the school to delay sending its paper applications (this is back in the mid-’90s) before the very first week of October. The due date was Nov. 1 with no extensions received towards the very early candidates. That was an annoying and angst-inducing experience for both my son and their parents. Things were various in those days, ahead of the advent for the electronic access candidates enjoy today.

Getting back once again to today, there is apparently plenty of irritation dwelling beneath and also at the top of these that are going into the application sweepstakes. I’d like to select some especially relevant commentary from this ‘angry’ thread and then add remarks from my viewpoint, where I have something substantive to say. Perhaps you’ll find one thing here which will press your hot key. Ideally, however, you will find some knowledge that will help avoid dilemmas this fall whenever you will likely be conducting your college that is own process.

The originator of this thread posits: ‘With college season coming up, wished to hear some rants about the admissions procedure. Actually, we hate the fact that you need to pay such fees that are expensive just connect with university!’

That motivated some interesting responses:

– I really dislike exactly how it forces young ones to start shaping their everyday lives to fit applications so early in life. After your early teens, anything you do is evaluated by exactly how valuable it is on an app.

We completely agree with this remark. I never gave a thought to how what I may have been doing would ‘look’ to a prospective college admissions committee when I was a teenager. Like Popeye, my mindset was really, ‘I have always been the things I am,’ and pretty much ‘we gotta be me.’ These days, some young adults (and their parents) check adolescence as one thing of the exercise that is scripted ‘becoming’ some kind of stereotyped young individual who will get big within the admissions lottery. That will maybe not make me personally ridiculously mad, but I am made by it sad.

– The actual fact that elite schools do not use exactly the same writing that is supplemental, essentially requiring pupils to write a distinctive essay for each application. It was exceptionally nerve-wracking for our entire family.

I am aware that elite schools may use these supplements to filter random applications from pupils who are underqualified or otherwise not truly interested — but OP just desired to understand me angry — and it did if it made.

The supplemental part associated with typical Application irritates me personally, too. My position is: Why can’t the Common Application be comprehensive enough by itself to remove the need for most of the information that is supplemental by different universities? Given, this would simply take some unification that is coordinated those schools (possibly beyond the so-called ‘elites’), but that could be time well invested, in my own view. an examination that is detailed of supplemental demands reveals overlap in the information required. I might greatly prefer every thing to be covered into the typical App itself, eliminating a complete large amount of more time and angst for the candidates.

How Are Late Bloomers Viewed?

– It annoys me personally that more advanced level subject knowledge (as demonstrated by AP and SATIIs) is valued less in admissions compared to the basic generic material and specific test taking skills (as demonstrated by ACT and SAT). The universities (especially general public) are simply simple saying ‘ We do not care just how much you like or understand your field that is future of! Just have the best grades and generic test ratings and possess an extended sufficient set of ECs.’

Overemphasis on GPA is playing a task, too. I believe it is absurd that 13-14-15 yr-olds are anticipated to be worried about university ‘resume’ by having straight As as to own that ‘perfect’ GPA. Think of how many brilliant ‘late bloomers’ the Ivys and such are lacking!

Having said all that, good or bad, the system can there be and all the kids are kept to do is play along. The only hope is that Einstein will be Einstein even though he goes through a community college at first.

Amen, especially to your ‘late bloomers’ reference. Just how many kids have a clear picture of just what their futures hold? Just how many have actually locked onto a passion that is real; about any such thing? I did not begin to appear dedicated to such a thing specific until I happened to be in my 30s that are later. Which was when I finally decoded the impact that is cumulative of liberal arts education and discovered my true calling. You’ve got to wonder how many ‘difference makers’ are turned away at ‘elite’ ( as well as other) schools since they don’t have the proper numerical profiles.

This subject reminds me personally of Princeton University’s late and Dean that is legendary of Fred Hargadon, whom, each admissions period, would reserve a small amount of slots for the people he thought had been diamonds in the rough. They don’t have the luster of all of the other Princeton admits, but Dean Fred inferred their potential and gave them an attempt at Old Nassau. There might be other admission deans nowadays willing to allocate ‘chance’ admits, but if you can find, I’m unacquainted with them.

– just How secretive colleges that are selective about their admission process and using bs terms like ‘holistic’. …

I discussed holistic admissions prior to. It can be deemed a ‘process’) is a two-edged sword for me, that process (if, indeed. Regarding the one hand, it gives the admissions committee latitude to check beyond the strict numerical aspects of an applicant’s profile and search for subjective aspects that could be of value up to a year that is particular course. The holistic approach lends itself to obfuscation on the other hand.

The validity of a applicant that is certain admission can invariably be relegated to ‘holistic’ factors. Sometimes I cannot help but think about holistic admissions within the sense that is same of saying about hot dogs: You don’t desire to observe they are made. Like the name of this forum thread, ‘ridiculously upset. if we knew the reason why behind some holistic admissions, we may find ourselves’

– It’s stupid just how much work that is busy made me do in senior school, which on top of my extracurricular tasks and my nearly nonexistent social life, provided me with hardly any rest throughout all four many years of senior school to produce me personally a ‘competitive applicant.’

This reminds me of Paul Simon’s song Kodachrome, where he says:

When I think straight back

On all the crap I discovered in senior high school

It’s really a wonder

I can think at all

And though my not enough education

Has not harm me none

I will see the writing regarding the wall

Obviously, there must be some sort of structure and curriculum preparation in senior school, nevertheless the stress associated with college procedure tends to backfire down through the system, thwarting some aspects of teenagers’s everyday lives. Luckily, i’ve were able to suppress all the ‘crap’ we discovered in senior school ( plus a large amount of essential material, too), so my psychological hard disk has freed up a lot of space for what actually matters, such as for instance catching all the good new films for March on Netflix or Amazon.

Financial Obligation Is Another Issue

Now, if i could add an added ongoing problem that produces me personally upset about the university admissions process, it would be the ‘ridiculously’ high amount of loans university students need certainly to obtain in order to complete their degrees. You may already know, i am not afraid to jump up on my soapbox and preach concerning the perils of loan financial obligation.

This brings me towards the problem of consequences. Just I saw this news article today:

Florida Board of wellness suspends hundreds of healthcare licenses over education loan defaults — That headline alone must certanly be sufficient to sober any college student up that is thinking about tossing care to the wind about taking on loans, thinking, ‘There’s no genuine penalty for blowing off re payments.’ Check always this down, from the article:

Nearly 1,000 medical care workers have lost their license to apply in Florida since they can not repay their figuratively speaking a crackdown that is new placing hundreds out of work, the I-Team discovered.

The proceed to suspend medical care licenses uses federal student loan businesses invested years lobbying states to adopt laws and regulations to punish those who default on student education loans by firmly taking away their professional licenses. …

Yikes. Now that’s a result … of blowing down loan re payments. What makes me personally furious about loan debt is that it is so easy to fall under. I won’t rehash my sermons that are past this. Just be aware of the old saying: there isn’t any such thing as being a free lunch [or student loan].

To put a cap on all this, we’ll offer this parting advice to vexed high schoolers and their parents about preparing to enter the college process: act as who you are, despite the pressures that are negative. In many situations, then things turn out for the best if you do!